May 9, 2010

Classical Kids...Latin

"I would make everyone learn English; then I would let the clever ones learn Latin as an honor, and Greek as a treat." Sir Winston Churchill

When I first heard about teaching latin to children I was intrigued, but I hesitated because I just wasn't sure that it wouldn't be a real chore to get them to do it. All my previous exposure to children and latin was that they dreaded it. I had never had latin, could I teach it and to someone who didn't want to learn it. Sounded like a headache to me. But I was persuing a classical model for education in our home so I just kept on reading more about it and as I read on I was hooked. 

The first Stage of the Trvium is called several names; the poll parrot stage, the grammar stage, knowledge stage; it is a time when the child is absorbing facts. They really are most at home with exploration, discovery and new ideas. They enjoy chanting and rote learning. They like rules and bits of info. It is a time to nourish thier minds with a banuqet of ideas and give them a broad education, as Charlotte Mason would say. It is a time to learn the fundamentals and pieces which make up the different disciplines. They are also quite adept at learning languages. I have known several grammar school aged kids who somehow understand and sort out three to six languages which they encounter daily in their mulitlingual lives. This is why they can begin latin vocab or chants at and early age. The preparation and filling makes the next two stages much more doable and enjoyable. It draws upon their ability at this age to absorb language and thier natural hunger for facts. In our homeschool we are learning chants and vocabulary of familar things like parts fo the body and animals. It is all verbal thus far. We have fun with it.

So why Latin?
Latin is a dead language. No one speaks it anymore! But more than that, isn't it true that whatever advantages you can claim for studying Latin, you'd also gain from studying virtually any language?
The fact that it is dead means...

1. It follows "the rules" more closely than do modern languages. Therefore,
2. Latin is easier to learn -- you don't have to memorize all the exceptions to the rules!
3. You don't have to learn how to converse in it. Therefore,
4. You can study Latin far more efficiently than any other language.
"Normal" foreign language programs devote about half of their time to teaching students simply how to say (pronounce) and hear (recognize) common phrases in the language.
With Latin, you don't have to devote any mental energy and time learning how to engage in conversation. Instead, you learn the underlying vocabulary, grammar and syntax (sentence structure).
5. When you study Latin, you can spend more time in actual translation -- carefully comparing and contrasting the meanings of words, phrases, and sentences in the two languages (in this case, English and Latin). This, in turn, hammers home the skills, concepts, and lessons you are learning through all the rest of your language study.
Besides the benefits that arise from the fact that Latin is "dead," here are several more major advantages. Among them:
Latin is a highly inflected language.
Languages in which the exact meanings and uses of words are indicated by the words' endings are called "inflected" languages. Such languages are different from English in which the position of the word in a sentence determines its exact meaning.
Consider the sentence, "The car hit the dog."
There are two nouns in the sentence: "car" and "dog." In English, we can tell which of these two nouns is the subject of the sentence (i.e., which one did the hitting) and which is the object (i.e., which received the hit) by where they are found in the sentence.
Because it comes first, we know that the car is the subject; it did the hitting. And because it comes second, we know that the dog is the object; it received the hit. Besides their order in the sentence, there are no other clues that tell us what function these nouns fulfill.
In Latin, by contrast, you can tell what is the subject and what is the object not by its position in the sentence (words can be in just about any order imaginable), but, rather, by the structure of the words themselves-their endings. (Does the word end with -a? If so, it is the subject. Does it end with -am? If so, then it is the object. And so forth.)
By studying Latin, then,
6. You will come to really know how languages "work." You will come to fully understand both of the two common methods whereby human beings communicate their meanings. And that means,
7. All subsequent language study becomes relatively simple.
As one gentleman, who is fluent in eight languages, declared, "Latin is such a good specimen language, even though Russian is from a completely different language family, my Latin helped me to learn Russian!"
8. You gain a much deeper understanding of English grammar.
By learning to understand this language that is so "other" than what you are used to, you will be forced to compare and contrast it to the English with which you are familiar. And through this comparison and contrast, you gain a much fuller understanding of English.
There is another major reason young people should study Latin:
Latin has had a greater impact on our language and culture than any other foreign language.
Did you know that over 60 percent of modern English words are based on Latin? The fact that so much English is based on Latin has several benefits. Among others:
9. Most students have already done a lot of the work to learn Latin vocabulary; they did it when they learned English!
10. If a person has a good grasp of the Latin roots of modern English words, s/he enjoys an unparalleled advantage when it comes to accurate spelling, especially spelling of complex and less familiar words.
As a result of all the benefits listed above,
11. Latin study appears to yield a consistent and demonstrable gain in standardized college entrance exam scores in both the Verbal and Math spheres -- a gain that no other language seems to offer.
Verbal scores of Latin students on the SAT are, on average, anywhere from 25 to 30 points all the way up to over 60 to 80 points ahead of the verbal scores of students studying other foreign languages.
Is there a cause-and-effect relationship between Latin study and high scores on standardized tests? No one can prove it. But based on the testimony of those who have studied Latin, and their personal impressions about the kinds of analytic skills they have developed and the personal confidence they have acquired as a result of studying Latin, I am strongly inclined to agree with those who say that it is, indeed, the study of Latin that increases students' competency, not some innate competency in the students that leads them to choose Latin for their foreign language study.  (Points 1-11 are from the  Sonlight Website)
"I will say it once, quite firmly, that the best grounding for education is the Latin grammer. I say this, not because Latin is traditional and mediaeval, but simply because even a rudimentry knowledge of Latin cuts down the labour and pains of learning almost any other subject by at least fifty percent. It is the key to the vocabulary and structure of all the Romance languages and to the structure of all the Teutonic languages, as well as to the technical vocabulary of all sciences and to the literature of the entire Mediterranean civilisation, together with all it's historic documents."
Dorthy Sayers

1 comment:

  1. Hi there!

    As I was passing through several homeschool blogs I came across yours as a favorite of another homeschool mother's. It is absolutely wonderful! You have such a creative and engaging way of educating your kids that I can see why your ideas are inspirational to others.

    I noticed on your blog that your are teaching your kids Latin. I've been educated through the Christian classical tradition and learned Latin for several years. I can tell you that it has made all the difference in the world when it comes to my education and in learning other languages. I'm very grateful for it!

    I wanted to tell you about Visual Latin. It's a great combination of videos and exercises for learning Latin. We've tried to make learning the language as enjoyable as possible. A lot of this has to do with our teacher, Dwane Thomas. Dwane actually taught me Latin so I can testify to his excellence as a teacher. He's great and makes what could be dense work into an enjoyable journey learning a language that is foundational to Western history, philosophy, history, art, and science. The great thing about the program is that you can work through it as slowly or quickly as you like. It's portable, so you can do lessons anywhere and if you miss anything you can simply rewind and watch again. It employs the three methods one needs to master a language: reading, writing and speaking the language. It's a wonderful curriculum in and of itself. It can also be used as a new perspective to freshen up lessons.

    Right now we offer a full semester's course in 2 discs. Each disc contains 10 lessons. You can actually preview a lesson here if you have a few minutes:

    I would love to give you a 25% discount on our product if you are interested. Please feel free to email me and we can chat more. My email is

    I hope you and your family had a wonderful Thanksgiving! I look forward to hearing from you.

    Visual Latin